I am Alex Snelling and I am the Executive Director of Professional and Ethical Standards.
Professional and Ethical Standards, or PES, investigates allegations of employee misconduct within the department. PES handles each case in a fair, proportionate and timely manner, always prioritising the protection of students while and upholding professional standards.
The purpose of an investigation is to establish the facts and determine whether the employee engaged in the conduct alleged. Importantly, no finding is made about whether the employee engaged in the alleged conduct until the conclusion of an investigation.
PES investigation overview
All reports about employee conduct concerns are received and assessed by PES' Preliminary Investigation Team.
In some cases, external agencies, such as NSW Police or the Department of Communities and Justice may need to be notified. PES also ensures that the department meets its statutory obligations by making notifications of reportable conduct to the Office of the Children's Guardian or serious wrongdoing to the Independent Commission Against Corruption.
When a matter requires further investigation, it is assigned to an investigator, who gathers evidence and compiles an investigation report for the delegated decision maker's consideration.
At any point, a delegated decision maker may decide to take remedial action or finalise the matter.
Following a finding of misconduct, the decision-maker can choose from a range of actions. These include taking no further action, issuing a caution and reprimand, imposing a fine, demoting, directing resignation, or dismissing the employee.
Reporting and preliminary assessment
Hi my name is Nicole Macfarlane and I am the director investigations of the preliminary investigations team.
Let's examine this process in more detail.
All staff are encouraged to use the PES reporting guide to determine whether to make a report or initiate direct management action. Additionally, the Guidance on misconduct offers practical advice to principals and managers on managing conduct concerns.
Allegations are received by phone or online form.
The Senior Officer reviews available records and statements, manage risks, and may seek additional information to decide whether an investigation is necessary.
They then decide whether to:
- Take no further action
- Refer the matter to another part of the department for action
- Refer it to the principal or workplace manager for direct management action
- Take remedial action or
- Undertake a further investigation
Of the roughly 4,500 matters reported to PES each year, only a small proportion require a full investigation.
Investigation
Hi, I’m Adam Cook, one of the PES Investigators.
- When a matter requires investigation, the assigned investigator begins by developing an investigation plan and a risk management plan. The employee subject to the allegation is notified about the allegations and can respond, including suggesting witnesses to be contacted. This information is considered part of the investigation.
- Evidence is gathered through witness interviews, site visits, document reviews, and expert advice.
- The investigator analyses the evidence and drafts allegations, which are sent to the employee for response.
- If the employee provides new and relevant information, further investigation may be undertaken.
- The investigator prepares a comprehensive report including all relevant evidence and the employee’s submissions.
The report is reviewed and endorsed by a director.
Decision making
Hi, my name is Amanda Sharwood and I am the director investigations.
The final decisions are made by a Director Investigation or the Executive Director PES, who are independent from the investigator.
They review the complete case file, including the investigation report and any employee submissions, and make preliminary findings.
If contemplating a serious outcome such as demotion, directing resignation, or dismissal of a permanent employee, the Disciplinary Advisory Panel convenes. This panel includes senior staff with HR, Legal, and School Operations expertise who provide perspectives on the misconduct, context, and any mitigating or aggravating factors.
The decision-maker then finalises findings and proposed actions, inviting the employee to respond.
After considering the response (if provided), the decision-maker makes the final determination and advises the employee in writing.
Some things to remember
- If you are dissatisfied with how PES is handling a matter, you may raise concerns with the investigator, the team director, or email executivedirector.pes@det.nsw.edu.au.
- There is no internal review process following a PES investigation.
- External appeal rights may exist with the Industrial Relations Commission or a court, but strict time limits apply, so it is important to act quickly and seek independent advice.
Support
- Anyone involved and impacted in the investigation is encouraged to seek support:
- Employees can access the Employee Assistance Program and their relevant union or professional body if they are members.
- Students can contact the School Counselling Service or school welfare team.
- General practitioners or community health services are also available.
- In a crisis, call the NSW Mental Health Line on 1800 011 511 or Lifeline on 13 11 44.