Investigations - Advice for employees under investigation

In this bulletin, we respond to issues often raised by employees under investigation.

In short

PES seeks to ensure its investigations are fair and timely. The investigator is your key contact to guide you through the process and provide regular updates on the investigation’s progress.

Your key contact at PES and getting updates

The investigator is your key contact at PES. You or your representative can contact the investigator or their director if you would like information about the investigation process or progress.


Purpose of investigations and PES' role

Investigations undertaken by PES aim to establish the facts about alleged misconduct so that a decision maker can take appropriate action. The decisions can range from taking no further action to the dismissal of an employee.

When addressing misconduct, the department seeks to:

  • ensure the safety and protection of children as the paramount consideration
  • maintain appropriate standards of conduct and work related performance for employees
  • protect and enhance the integrity and reputation of the department, its teaching service, staff administrative and support staff and the public service
  • conduct investigations in a procedurally fair and timely manner, providing employees with an opportunity to respond if an adverse finding is contemplated
  • ensure that the public interest is protected.

Specific guidelines and legislative arrangements are in place for some employees.

The Guidelines for the Management of Conduct and Performance (the Guidelines) apply to all permanent officers and employees of the department employed under the following legislation:

The Guidelines extend to temporary employees, under these employment Acts, in the following circumstances:

  • where an employee is charged with a serious offence
  • where an employee is charged with and/or convicted of serious sex offences, or offences against children that would mean they are prohibited from engaging in child-related work.

The Government Sector Employment Act 2013 and associated rules set out the legislative framework for managing unsatisfactory performance and misconduct by a person employed under that Act.


Stages of the investigation process

Most investigation will follow these key stages:

  • Preliminary assessment of allegation/s
    Includes: school based enquiries which may include written versions of events, determining whether to investigate, allocating an investigator, addressing risks to all parties.
  • Information gathering
    Includes: interviewing witnesses, notifying the employee, seeking information and nominated witnesses from the employee, case planning, gathering documents, interviewing witnesses.
  • Putting allegations to the employee
    Includes: analysing the evidence, drafting allegations, seeking a response from the employee to the allegations.
  • Report writing
    Includes: analysing evidence and submissions, drafting an investigation report and endorsement by a PES investigation director.
  • Preliminary findings
    Includes: decision maker reading the evidence and report, making sustained/not sustained findings on each allegation, if the allegation is sustained whether the conduct amounts to reportable conduct (child protection investigations), seeking additional information. If misconduct is not found, the employee will be advised and the investigation will be closed at this point.
  • Proposing action
    Includes: writing to the employee proposing what action (if any) will be taken, providing the employee with an opportunity to make submission on any adverse action.
  • Finalising action
    Includes: advising the employee and relevant parties of the findings, whether reportable conduct has occurred and the action that will be taken.


Preliminary investigations

Allegations are received by phone or online form. The Senior Officer reviews available records and statements, manages risks, and may seek additional information to decide whether an investigation is necessary or an alternative pathway is preferred.

They then decide whether to:

  • take no further action
  • refer the matter to another part of the department for action
  • refer it to the principal or workplace manager for direct management action
  • take remedial action which includes warnings, counselling, monitoring, training, placement on improvement programs and transfers
  • undertake a further investigation.

Of the roughly 4,500 matters reported to PES each year, only a small proportion require a full investigation.


Roles within the investigation process

Once a decision has been made that a full investigation should commence, an investigator is assigned to the case. The investigator gathers evidence, considers any submissions you provide and writes an investigation report. Each investigator is attached to a team with a director who oversees the investigation process and endorses the final report.

Decisions about findings and action to be taken are made by PES' Executive Director or a director independent from the investigation.

The Disciplinary Advisory Panel regularly meets to provide advice to the executive director on matters where they are contemplating demoting, directing to resign or dismissing a permanent employee.


Risk management

Careful consideration has been given to the investigation processes which consider the wellbeing and safety of all parties. PES’ investigation practices consider the psychosocial impacts on parties which are addressed through standarised features of the investigation process. This includes clear information about our processes, referrals to support services, opportunities to provide your views, regular meaningful updates and the contact details of the investigator.

Investigators develop risk assessments that consider the employee, the alleged victim, students, witnesses and the investigation. Risk management strategies may involve additional measures or supports that reduce risk. This can include lawful directions to an employee that limit or require certain actions, referrals to specific services and local strategies to reduce contact between parties.

There are legal requirements under the Children’s Guardian Act 2019 and Public Interest Disclosure Act 2022 to undertake a risk assessment.

Investigators consider the risks to in a case by looking at the evidence available and consulting with workplace managers about appropriate risk treatments.

The main priority when deciding to remove an employee from duty is to protect students. Other factors include:

  • Nature and strength of the allegations
  • Employee’s current duties and location
  • Public interest
  • Efficient department operation
  • Maintaining good order and discipline
  • Withdrawal of necessary credentials including WWCC.

Common risk management strategies in investigations include:

  • Providing clear information to parties about the investigation process
  • Monitoring of conduct and interactions in the workplace
  • Changes to classes or duties
  • Written directions about the expected standards of conduct during an investigation
  • Warnings about detrimental action against witnesses.

If risks cannot be safely managed for a permanent or ongoing employee in a workplace, these steps may be taken:

  • Move the employee to another location in the same role
  • Move the employee to another location with different duties
  • Suspend the employee with pay
  • Suspend the employee without pay.


Alternative duties and suspensions

Alternative duties and suspensions with or without pay are further risk mitigation strategies used where other risk mitigation strategies are insufficient to manage risk. Decisions about alternative duties are made by senior officers in PES. An employee can seek a review of a decision to put them on alternatives duties or a period of suspension. In considering this review request, the Executive Director PES will seek the advice of the Disciplinary Advisory Panel.

The department is committed to providing employees on alternative duties with meaningful work. The department’s Alternative Duties Support Team, situated in the Public Schools division, assists workplace managers to identify and allocate work based on an employee’s skills and abilities.


Providing early submissions and nominating witnesses for PES to interview

An employee at the point of notification can make a submission about:

  • their version of events regarding the incident(s)
  • the names and details of witnesses who have direct knowledge of the matters under investigation and who they believe should be spoken to by the investigator.

Employees are not required to provide information to PES and will have additional opportunities to provide information during the disciplinary process.


Factors affecting timeliness

PES is committed to addressing allegations of misconduct in a timely, efficient, fair and thorough manner. PES upholds transparent communication by providing progress updates at least once per school term and outlining reasons for any delays. Common causes of investigation delays include:

  • Involvement of external agencies: E.g., NSW Police, Department of Communities and Justice, Office of the Children’s Guardian, Independent Commission Against Corruption. Investigations may be placed on hold awaiting these agencies’ outcomes.
  • Volume and complexity of evidence: Collection and review of interviews, statements, computer records, CCTV footage, and other materials can be time intensive.
  • Need for expert advice: Forensic analysis or input from legal, audit, or health professionals.
  • Health and wellbeing considerations: Taking account of the physical and mental health of employees under investigation, witnesses, and alleged victims.
  • Emergence of new allegations or lines of inquiry: Fairness requires these to be fully investigated, which can effectively reset investigation timeliness.
  • Competing urgent priorities: Matters impacting student or staff safety and wellbeing receive precedence.
  • Requests for extensions: For legal advice or preparing submissions.
  • Oversight body reviews: While important, responding to external scrutiny or complaints can cause delays.
  • Administrative and procedural demands: Includes transcription of interviews, managing extensive documentation, coordinating multiple stakeholders, and complying with legislative reporting.

More than one in four investigations are placed on hold as a direct result of external factors outside the control of PES.

For more information, access the Investigation timeliness bulletin.


Serious offences

A serious offence under employment legislation and the department’s Code of ethics and conduct is an offence that is punishable by imprisonment for 12 months or more

PES will take risk management action but is required to wait for the outcome of police investigations and criminal proceedings before commencing processes to address the charges.

Action can be taken against members of the teaching service and school administrative and support staff found guilty of a serious offence (with or without conviction) without an investigation. Instead, a decision maker will consider the appropriate action based on the courts findings and material obtained from the criminal proceedings. The employee is provided with the opportunity to make submissions about the proposed action

However, where the employee is convicted of serious sex offence or offences against children that results in them being barred from engaging in child-related work (as defined by the Child Protection (Working with Children) Act 2012 or they fail to obtain the appropriate working with children clearance, they are considered to be unauthorised. Following a person becoming unauthorised the dismissal takes effect immediately and the employee or temporary employee will not have any right to provide a response or to an interview.

The person will be advised in writing as soon as practicable that they have been dismissed, or in the case of a temporary employee, that their contract has been terminated.


Involvement of another agency or a court

PES will report matters to other agencies where it has a legal responsibility to do so. This includes sharing information about the safety welfare and wellbeing of children.

PES may be limited in how we can progress an investigation where another external investigating body has requested that the department’s process be deferred while it carries out an investigation.

These organisations include NSW Police, the Department of Communities and Justice, Office of the Children’s Guardian, NSW Ombudsman, SafeWork NSW or the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC).

PES will wait for the decision of a court when the matters under investigation are being dealt with through a criminal process.


Making submissions

You have multiple opportunities to make submissions during an investigation.

  • You will be notified that your conduct is under investigation and provided preliminary information about the allegations identified you will be invited to provide information which could assist the investigation.
  • You will be provided with the opportunity to respond to the complete allegation/s of misconduct.
  • You will have the opportunity to respond to the preliminary findings, any preliminary reportable conduct findings and the proposed disciplinary action prior to a final decision being reached.

You are not required to make a submission during an investigation and your decision not to provide a response will always be respected. However, a decision will be taken based on the available information.

You should seek advice early about the course of action that is appropriate to your circumstances.

If you need more time, an application for an extension will be considered on its merits. You need to keep in mind that this may delay the investigation. In deciding on an extension PES will look at the overall circumstances and balance the need to ensure fairness with the need to progress the matter.


Nominated witnesses

PES encourages advising the investigator early about potential witnesses who may have observed or been involved in an incident. The investigator uses professional judgement about how to conduct the investigation and may not approach every witness that is nominated.

The investigation report will document why a witness nominated by an employee was not approached. Circumstances where a nominated witness may not be interviewed include but are not limited to:

  • where there is information that approaching a witness may adversely impact on their welfare
  • where permission from a parent of a child witness cannot be obtained
  • a witness attesting solely to an employee’s character and not to the matters subject to investigation
  • where the nominated witness cannot be identified or is too broad including the nomination of a whole class of students
  • where a sufficient sample of witnesses have been approached to provide a balanced account of the matters subject to investigation.


Approaching or taking detrimental action against a witness

You must not discuss the investigation or evidence with potential witnesses without first seeking the agreement of the investigator as it may contaminate the investigation process. You should instead nominate the person as a witness for the investigator to approach.

It is a criminal offence under section 64 of the Children’s Guardian Act 2019 to take, or threaten to take, detrimental action in respect of a person who reports or proposes to report, in good faith, a reportable allegation. It also is a criminal offence under section 33 of the Public Interest Disclosures Act 2022 to take detrimental action against a person based on a suspicion, belief, or awareness that a person has made, may have made or may make a public interest disclosure (PID).


Providing character references

Character reference or character witnesses do not assist a decision maker in deciding whether or not conduct has occurred. A person’s character has little evidentiary weight when deciding whether a person has engaged in misconduct.


Confidentiality

Care is taken by PES to maintain confidentiality. This protects the integrity of the investigation process and preserves the privacy of the parties concerned. However, there are limits to confidentiality and in some circumstances information will need to be disclosed. PES may need to disclose information to:

  • ensure the safety of parties and to manage risk
  • progress an investigation
  • meet legal obligations to share or report information to other agencies including NSW Police or the Department of Communities and Justice
  • ensure fairness for an employee subject to allegations including providing:
    • names of victims and witnesses so that an employee can respond to the allegations
    • evidence collected and relied on to make findings where disciplinary action is proposed so the employee can respond to the proposed action.

All witnesses, including you and your support person, are advised to maintain confidentiality and not discuss the matter except for the purposes of the investigation, obtaining legal advice/union support and/or in relation to your personal health or support needs.

It is never appropriate to discuss an investigation in open forums such as school assemblies, general staff meetings, social media pages or community forums.


Support for you

Being involved in an investigation can be overwhelming. Your welfare is important and you are encouraged to seek support early in the process. Support is available to help employees during the investigation process. This includes:

  • the Employee Assistance Program (EAP) on 1800 951 198 is available to all staff employed by the department and their immediate family members.. Immediate telephone support is available 24/7, 365 days a year. Contact on 1800 951 198 or go to About EAP
  • the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander booking support line (EAP) on 1800 816 152
  • the NSW Teachers Federation (for members) on 9217 2100 or toll free on 1300 654 369
  • the Public Service Association (PSA) (for members) on 1300 772 679
  • the NSW Primary Principals’ Association (NSWPPA) (for members) Professional Support Officers who can be contacted on 0429 547 619
  • the Secondary Principals’ Council (NSWSPC) Professional Support Officers who can be contacted on 0461 380 783
  • your general practitioner or local community health service.

In a crisis you can also contact the NSW Mental Health Line on 1800 011 511 or Lifeline on 13 11 14.


Leave or illness during an investigation

Employees should ensure that they are contactable during an investigation. In addition to the usual leave approval processes, PES will be consulted about the leave arrangements. Long absences may not be approved, particularly if an employee cannot be contacted.

If you become ill during an investigation it is important that you advise the investigator about the best way for you to receive information or correspondence about the investigation. In some cases we can provide information through a legal representative, union support or a medical practitioner to ensure you receive an appropriate level of support.

PES may require evidence of illness from a medical practitioner including their opinion as to your fitness to take part in an investigation where it impacts on the progress of an investigation.

The need to ensure fairness to an employee will be weighed against the department’s duty to respond to and finalise matters in a timely way.


Resignation or retirement

Any resignation or retirement request by an employee subject to an investigation must be referred to the investigator. Resignations or retirements are reviewed by the relevant PES director who has discretion to accept or refuse them. If required, advice will be sought from the Executive Director, PES.

The employment acts allow for disciplinary action to be taken even though the officer has retired or resigned. Investigations can be continued even after your employment has ceased.


Role of your support person

The role of the support person is to provide you with practical and emotional support.

Your support person may act as a witness to any meetings or interviews you attend during the investigation process. They help safeguard against unfair practices.

A specific bulletin on the role of a support person during an investigation is available.


Allegations about others

Allegations against another employee may be raised in the course of an investigation. PES will assess these matters and may ask relevant parties for supporting information. PES will continue to investigate the original conduct while completing an assessment of the additional allegations.


Possible outcomes

If the decision maker determines that misconduct has occurred, they have the following options which can be used in combination.


Permanent/Ongoing
  • Remedial – warning, counselling, monitoring, training, improvement program, transfer
  • Misconduct recorded with no further action
  • Caution and reprimand
  • Fine
  • Salary reduction or demotion
  • Direction to resign
  • Dismissal
  • Not to be employed listing
Temporary/Casual
  • Misconduct recorded with no further action
  • Warning
  • Termination
  • Conditional casual approval
  • Not to be employed listing

Not to be employed list (NTBE)

The Teaching Service Act 1980 and the Education (School Administrative and Support Staff) Act 1987 allows the department to prepare and maintain a list of persons who the Secretary determines are not to be employed. A person can be placed on this list even if the person was not previously employed by the department.

The NTBE list restricts a person from being employed including as a volunteer or third-party contractor. Individuals on the NTBE list are not permitted to enter school premises except to attend events featuring a family member or significant person, such as a student. The list is held on a confidential database accessed by staff when assessing whether a person should be employed. A person can be placed temporarily on the NTBE list as a risk mitigation strategy or permanently at the conclusion of an investigation, preventing future employment.


What records are kept

Full details of all investigations are stored digitally and held under restricted access by PES.

Where misconduct is found a notation is placed on the employee’s personnel file. It references that a PES investigation has occurred, that misconduct was found and any action that has been taken.

A record is not made on the employee’s personnel file where misconduct is not found to have occurred.


Reportable Conduct and the Working with Children Check (WWCC)

PES is required to make a finding about reportable conduct in child related allegations. It is important that you consider and seek advice about the possible nature of child related allegations and the reportable conduct scheme.

Making a finding of reportable conduct: The NSW Reportable Conduct Scheme – Fact Sheet 8 provides further information about the elements a decision maker will consider in determining whether reportable conduct has occurred.

Employees may at anytime make submissions about whether they believe their conduct constitutes reportable conduct and will be advised of preliminary findings about whether the conduct constitutes reportable conduct.

Where PES makes a finding of sexual misconduct, a sexual offence or a serious physical assault the Office of the Children’s Guardian (OCG) is prompted to re-assess the employee’s WWCC.

There are other considerations including relevant and disqualifying offences which impact on an employee’s WWCC.

The decision to place an interim bar or ongoing bar on an employee’s WWCC is determined by the OCG independent of PES.

Further information about the type of matters considered by the OCG in relation to WWCC is available.


Information shared with victims (and families) makers of voluntary public interest disclosures (VPID)

Under the Children’s Guardian Act 2019 PES must communicate relevant information about investigations to alleged victims and their families where an employee is alleged to have engaged in reportable conduct towards them. This includes the progress of an investigation, the findings and the action taken.

PES is required under the Public Interest Disclosure (PID) Act 2022 to communicate relevant information to the makers of a VPID regarding an investigation into serious wrongdoing. This includes the progress of an investigation, a description of the results of the investigation and details of the action taken.

PES shares information with victims and impacted parties to ensure they have confidence that their matter has been investigated and actioned appropriately. The level of information shared will give consideration to the lawful basis to release information, the public interest and personal safety.


Reviews

There is no right to an internal review or appeal of a disciplinary decision made by a delegated decision maker. However, you may be able to explore external review options.

The Industrial Relations Commission deals with disciplinary appeals in line with the Industrial Relations Act 1996 for public sector employees. Section 97 of the Act sets out the type of disciplinary decisions which can be reviewed. There may be other legal avenues you can consider and you should seek your own legal advice.


Complaints

A complaint can be made regarding how a matter is being investigated. Initially, you or your representative should try to resolve the issue directly with the investigator. If the concern cannot be resolved promptly, you may escalate it to the investigator’s director.

If informal attempts do not resolve the matter, a formal complaint can be submitted to the Executive Director of PES at ExecutiveDirector.PES@det.nsw.edu.au.

A complaint will not result in the review of final action taken against an employee including disciplinary actions.


Specific advice and policy

For specific advice about your matter speak to the Professional and Ethical Standards (PES) investigator allocated to the investigation and consult the department’s Professional and Ethical Standards Policy.


Business Unit:

  • Professional and Ethical Standards
Return to top of page Back to top